O doctor, where art thou? Telemedicine allows doctors to see patients thousands of miles away
By Kendall Madden
The Stanford Daily
A patient walks into a clinic in a rural town in India, talks to a doctor, receives a diagnosis and a prescription, and leaves the office. Sounds like a normal visit to the doctor, doesn’t it? Except in this case, the doctor is thousands of miles away and conversed with the patient via video camera.
Impossible? Don’t tell that to Stanford doctors.
Rather than traveling around the world to visit patients, American and Indian doctors are hoping to revolutionize medicine in rural areas with a package of technologies known as telemedicine, through which patients correspond with a doctor through videoconferencing, audio communication technology and e-mail.
Doctors are in desperate need in rural areas around the world. In many developing countries, the idea of an accessible general practice doctor is dream — a specialist is even less likely. In rural India, for example, there is one doctor on average for every 15,500 people. Specialists are only found in the metropolitan areas that are not accessible for the majority of the rural population.
Many enterprises are springing up on the basis of new telemedicine technology to alleviate the scarcity of doctors and specialists in these other areas of the world.
One such telemedicine enterprise is currently under development at Stanford in conjunction with the Digital Vision Fellows Program. The Global Telemedicine Project, initiated and directed by Dr. Renée J. Chin and Dr. Jack Higgins, is an innovative attempt to mobilize the skills of doctors in the wealthiest countries to provide care for individuals in developing countries.
The Project is working with a community in Kuppam, India, in partnership with Hewlett Packard’s E-Inclusion program. HP’s program consists of two vans equipped with computers that circulate through the community, providing Internet access and educational programs. A third van is being designed as a mobile medical clinic and will contain computers for the purpose of telemedicine consultations.
“Our vision for the Global Telemedicine Project is to develop a database of physicians from all over the world to serve patients in rural communities like India, South Africa or Vietnam,” Chin said.
“Where programs like Doctors Without Borders and the Peace Corps require volunteer health practitioners to travel for extended periods of time, the Global Telemedicine Project will ask volunteers to commit to only about four to eight hours per month,” Chin said.
Most importantly, doctors, specialists and health practitioners will be able to work from their own home or office”
The Project is modeled after a domestic program, founded by Higgins, called the HouseCall Foundation. Using the similar telemedicine, HouseCall connects a free clinic in San Jose to a diabetes treatment center in Redwood City.
The technology itself is simple, according to visions held by the Higgins and Chin plan. The Project will work in conjunction with Video HouseCall Network, the operator of a Web-based telemedicine system of audio- and video-conferencing.
In some cases a live, real-time consultation may not be possible and will be substituted with a “store-and-forward” system of video clips, photographs and text messages. Since the information can be transmitted over the Internet, the only hardware required is a laptop computer and small video camera, the latter of which could be acquired used, costing approximately $50 to 250.
According to Higgins, the HouseCall program has been extremely successful. He said he hopes for the same positive results from the new global initiative. Before the project may be implemented, significant research into the region and the community of Kuppam must be carried out.
Chin, an ethnographer whose research has centered on the role of technology in community dynamics and healthcare systems, emphasized the need for an ecological perspective in development of the project.
“Approaching the project from an ‘ecological perspective’ means that we are interested in the relationships and interactions between a people and their environment as part of their relationship to health and health care,” Chin explained.
“For example, health practices and caring for one’s health is done within social networks, that is, family, friends, and community activities,” she continued. “Compliance with medicines and learning new health practices such as washing hands more often may have more success if the social network is included in the prescription.”
Though the Global Telemedicine Project is not the first such program to use telemedicine technology to reach rural, developing communities, it differs from existing programs in that it hopes to provide direct care from doctor to patient.
Telemedicine initiatives have been increasingly popular in India as method of improving rural healthcare, but the structure has largely been to provide specialist skills in regions where there is only a general practice doctor. Doctors in rural settings rarely have the special training necessary for certain procedures and diagnoses.
Telemedicine is often a cheaper alternative to sending specialists to the rural regions to practice. Such initiatives within India have, therefore, aimed at providing rural patients with the opportunity to be examined by a specialist if a rural doctor is unqualified, and they also provide the means of instructing rural doctors in skills that they might not have and training them for some specialist procedures.
Telemedicine technology also enables rural doctors to consult with their urban peers in the process of a surgery or complicated procedure. The Global Telemedicine Project hopes to reach out to even more of the under-served population by eliminating the need for the on-site doctor.
Chin and Higgins plan on having the telemedicine system up and running by December of this year, with the ultimate goal of expanding to other developing countries.
“When I let myself dream about it,” Higgins said, “I imagine this growing big and spreading out: A revolution of the way healthcare is provided the world over.”
For the full text of this article, click here

December 9th, 2004 at 10:26 pm
Hello Kendall Madden,
I read your article & I really do hope that your views are materialized on ground.
I am working in an ICT project for over an period of one & half year and I and our focus was on telemedicine. We ran he telemedicine from a rural village Ari ,Block-Babai ,District- Hosangbad ,State- Madhya pradesh ,India.
The hole operation was carried out with the help of health worker in the village & the doctors from the People general hospital, Bhopal .We were able to provide a medical relief to about 40 patient and collected around Rs 400 ($10) dollars for a period of four month.
But i will tell you the kind of resistance we had to face in four month was so huge that at last it broke down our spine .Every one form local government ,local doctors ,our fellows ,other specialist doctors ,the telecom which provided us lines ,the people who worked for us & every one .
So i know how hard it is to run an telemedicine thing as it is really a very mental thing .It is very hard to convince the senior doctors, they always thrown spanner down the wheel.
But we have not given hope, we have installed wideband in 12 villages and we will make sure that our tele-medicine is successful. We have trained around 20-health worker in the area of tele-medicine. We will one day make the most of it .We will solve the medical problem of villagers.
thanks
with regards
sharad singh
June 29th, 2005 at 1:48 am
The article made a very interesting reading. It is true that rural health care in India is not at all existent. But what i would like to know is whether telemedicine is economically feasible. We are going to start a rural internet project shortly and in this context we are exploring telemedicine project. Could you help us?
August 8th, 2006 at 6:14 pm
Telemedicine is the future of global healthcare. It success affects us all. Keep up the good work.
JL
November 1st, 2006 at 1:51 am
This is a wonderful narration of how healthcare and skills of a single specialist can be taken to millions of undeprevileged people across the world. Telemedicine is revolutionarising the way we deliver healthcare today. I have been associated with Telemedicine since 3 years now, thanks to Apollo hospitals this healthcare delivery system is helping thousands of people every year. But, there are millions who needs to be reached. And, we will need several visionaries like Dr. Prathap Reddy to establish centers of excellence in rural India…. after all it is the farmers who is feeding us and we need to take the best of healthcare to the farmers of this country.
There is a huge disparity between the availability of medical facility and patient numbers, though 80% of Indian population resides in rural stretches just 20% of the total healthcare resources are availbale to them. Let us listen to what reality speaks, there are few takers for practiving in rural areas….. the reasons are obvious - lack of growth, development of family, poor infracture etc. Does that mean the rural dweller has no right to health? No…. the answer is Telemedicine.
November 5th, 2006 at 8:05 am
Since HDCAM SR offers a dual HD SDI option, recording 4:4:4 RGB video with an all but invisible compression, it is an option to use it instead of 2k. The resolution is quite similar (1,85:1 - 2048×1107 vs. 16:9 1920×1080) - and it is easier to handle. If the colorist knows what they’re doing this is quite attractive (and cost-effective) for independent film makers. It is done like that at some European post houses.
December 29th, 2006 at 6:48 am
It was good to meet you at Word on the Street on Sunday, Jim. I’m really getting into the book now, especially now the defilement has dried properly.